Reciprocal causation and the proximateultimate distinction. The presence of facial and bodily symmetry is an important health cue, reflecting an individuals ability to withstand environmental and genetic stressors6 122. Jun 05, 2016 for example, while discussing how social psychology and cultural evolution can inform one another,mesoudi 2009 wrote. Ultimate causes belong to its evolutionary history. For the notion of proximate cause in law, see proximate cause. In evolutionary biology, an answer to the question of why an individual behaves in a certain way can take two broad. A proximate explanation for the blind spot is this. Seghers, e proximate and ultimate factors in evolutionary thinking on art human ethology bulletin proc. Traditional social psychological explanations tend to explain behavior in terms of proximate situational cues or internal motivations, while evolutionary theories including cultural evolutionary theories provide ultimate.
Evolutionary ultimate explanations 1 function adaptation darwins theory of evolution by natural selection is the only scientific explanation for why an animals behaviour is usually well adapted for. Evolutionary theory and the ultimateproximate distinction in. For example, while discussing how social psychology and cultural evolution can inform one another,mesoudi 2009 wrote. An ultimate cause is the adaptive rationale that led the proximate cause to evolve, such as the need for nutrition and reproduction that gave us the drives of hunger and lust. Of these 15 books, 3 did not discuss the theoretical foundations of evolutionary psychology and were discarded from the analysis. By proximate level, wilson means the direct individual reasons motivating a behavior, ie pleasure from s e x, or contentment from love. In philosophy a proximate cause is an event which is closest to, or immediately responsible for causing, some observed result. Accor ding to mayr, proximate causes gover n the responses of the individual and his organs to immediate factors of the environment while ultimate causes are responsible for the evolution of the particular dna. One apparently plausible interpretation of this dichotomy is that proximate causes concern processes. Comparative psychology is an extension of work done in human and behavioral psychology.
In biology, physicochemical explanations are addressed by tinbergens questions on causation and ontogeny, which taken together are known as proximate causes. An evolutionary hypothesis for obsessive compulsive disorder. Evolutionary psychology is compatible with equity feminism. Tinbergens four questions, named after nikolaas tinbergen and based on aristotle s four causes, are complementary categories of explanations for behaviour. Tinbergen, 1951 devoted a significant portion 5 chapters to the development and psychological causes of selected behavior patterns. Ethology is an extension of genetics, evolution, anatomy, physiology, and other biological disciplines. Animal behaviour history and basic concepts britannica. Evolutionary theory recognises causation at ultimate and proximate levels. Proximate and ultimate dichotomy evolutionmedicine.
Accor ding to mayr, proximate causes gover n the responses of the individual. All of the proximate mechanisms that we list below are commonly known as potential causes of low mood and depression episodes, but they have not been previously identified as contributing to different depressive subtypes. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Proximate causes include hereditary, developmental, structural, cognitive, psychological, and physiological aspects of behaviour. Animal behavior has been studied for decades, by biologists in the science of ethology, by psychologists in the science of comparative psychology, and by scientists of many disciplines in the study of neurobiology. Proximate versus ultimate causation arises in animals from its ultimate cause that is, the evolutionary history and functional utility of the behaviour. Evolutionary theory and the ultimateproximate distinction. Ultimate causation refers to the supposed function of an adaptation or organ within the ancestral environment while proximate causes refer to all the possible physical factors that directly produce the given trait e. Proximate and ultimate questions in evolutionary medicine.
Evolutionary psychology is an approach that views human nature as the product of a universal set of evolved psychological adaptations to recurring problems in the ancestral environment. The proximateultimate distinction and evolutionary. You cant really understand anything important about evolutionary psychology. Proximate cause is the direct or apparently obvious cause of an event. The partnership between proximate and ultimate causation is particularly beneficial in evolutionary medicine. In evolutionary biology, an answer to the question of why an individual behaves in a certain way can take two broad, nonmutually exclusive forms. These are also commonly referred to as levels of analysis. The purpose of this article is to persuade readers that ultimate causes often exist alongside proximate causes. Behavioral biology is the study of the biological and evolutionary bases for such changes. Current scholars typically separate these into proximate and ultimate causes.
Depression subtyping based on evolutionary psychiatry. The proximateultimate distinction and evolutionary developmental biology. The idea that behaviors evolved as a result of the pressures of natural selection is not new. For example, if a zebra is drinking at a water hole, and all of a sudden it hears another zebra nearby make an alarm call, it may stop. The worth of integrating proximate and ultimate explanations is demonstrated by the ensuing novel insights of popular avenues of sport and exercise psychology including a the interrelation. One apparently plausible interpretation of this dichotomy is that proximate causes concern processes occurring during the life of an organism while ultimate causes refer to those processes particularly natural selection that shaped its genome. Once the major findings of behavioral ecology have been examined, the book turns its attention to the proximate mechanisms. Here, too, the emphasis remains on the evolutionary puzzles provided by particular developmental and neurophysiological mechanisms. In essence, the proximate ultimate distinction is that between the causes of behavior that occur within an animals lifetime and those that precede its life, i. In particular, proximate phenomena have been used to explain questions of ultimate causation.
Ultimate cause philosophy and behaviour britannica. Ernst mayr first cr eated the distinction between proximate and ultimate causes of behavior. Tinbergens four questions provide a comprehensive, logical approach to studying behavior that is particularly useful for indepth analysis. This failure of modelintegration theory is focused on behavioral systems i. The ultimate level is the selective advantage behind. Proximate and ultimate causes of ego depletion pdf. Proximate causes of characters occur during the life of the organism. We can read ultimate causes as evolutionary processes, among which mayr regards natural selection as the. Proximate explanations are closest to the event that is to be explained, while higher, ultimate explanations instead focus on the. Proximate and evolutionary studies of anxiety, stress and. Yet, proximate and ultimate causes deal with questions of how and why and both have applications in other fields. The painfully misunderstood distinction between ultimate and proximate explanations questionnaires measure conscious needs, not ultimate evolutionary causes. The underlying ideas inherent in the proximate ultimate distinction are not new.
For instance, a violent outburst may have a proximate cause of being insulted, but the remote cause may. Evolutionary theory and the ultimateproximate distinction in the human behavioral. Darwins books about evolution and reactions to them. Proximate and evolutionary studies of anxiety, stress and depression. Throughout his book, alcock uses his distinction between proximate functional purposes of social behavior and their ultimate evolutionary causes to clarify and elaborate upon his claims a typical dichotomy used to separate functional biology from evolutionary biology, including how sociobiology concerns itself chiefly with ultimate. It was written before the current fad for evolutionary psychology and brilliantly anticipates some of the key ideas of that later movement. Proximate cause is the immediate trigger for a behavior. The proximateultimate distinction, then, is claimed to give rise to an explanatory asymmetry. What goes on in our minds is influenced by our developmental experiences, and both ongoing phenomenology and psychological development are influenced by evolutionary history. This exists in contrast to a higher level ultimate cause.
Animal behaviorscope wikibooks, open books for an open world. Mayrs proximateultimate distinction has received renewed interest in recent years. Proximate and ultimate explanations are required for a. Here we discuss its role in arguments about the relevance of developmental to evolutionary biology. Vessey, bowling green state university, bowling green, oh, usa. The final section of the chapter highlights the key conclusions to be drawn from part ii of the book. They group broadly into questions about proximate and ultimate explanations. Ultimate level explanations provide the answer to why the behaviour exists. Neuroscience has made significant advances in exploring the proximate causes of psychopathology but relatively few studies have addressed evolutionary or ultimate causes of traits or disorders. Once the major findings of behavioral ecology have been examined, the book turns its attention to the proximate mechanisms underlying animal behavior. The painfully misunderstood distinction between ultimate. Proximate explanations neural, endocrine, and genetic mechanisms. Ultimate causation refers to the supposed function of an adaptation or organ within the ancestral environment while proximate. An ultimate explanation based on sexual selection states that females who display preferences have more vigorous or more attractive male offspring proximate causation explains biological function in terms of.
Here, too, the emphasis remains on the evolutionary puzzles provided by particular developmental and neurophysiological. Aug 10, 2008 by proximate level, wilson means the direct individual reasons motivating a behavior, ie pleasure from s e x, or contentment from love. Misinformation about evolution in textbooks pop psychology. Animal behaviorscope wikibooks, open books for an open. Humans and other primates respond negatively to the absence of. An evolutionary hypothesis for obsessive compulsive. Proximate causes mechanism and ontogeny mechanism is the physiology of behavior. A crucial task of evolutionary psychology 101 is to learn the difference between proximate and ultimate causation. It is worth clearly delineating between proximate and ultimate levels of explanation. The painfully misunderstood distinction between ultimate and. David haig department of organismic and evolutionary biology, harvard university, 26 oxford street, cambridge ma 028. In this article, we 1 evaluate the hypothesis that partner rape functions to dominate and control women, arguing that, as an ultimate explanation, this hypothesis is not compatible with modern evolutionary theory, 2 distinguish between proximate and ultimate explanations, 3. Evolutionary debunking arguments and the proximate.
For decades, several types of scientists have studied animal behavior. The distinction between proximate and ultimate causation in biology. Depression evolutionary factors psychology wiki fandom. The extra dimension of biology seeks explanations of biological phenomena in terms of function and evolutionary history, which together are known as ultimate causes. A proximate cause is an event which is closest to, or immediately responsible for causing, some observed result. We talked about the blind spot in the retina, for example. In this article, we 1 evaluate the hypothesis that partner rape functions to dominate and. As a result, ultimate explanations have enormous practical potential.
Feminist psychology needs to evolve by embracing equity feminism, which has no a priori stance on the origin or existence of. Ultimate causation explains traits in terms of evolutionary forces acting on them example. To gain a fuller understanding of why babies cry, it is necessary to analyze both the proximate and the ultimate causes. Nesse university of michigan, room 5057 isr, 426 thompson st. Apr, 2017 the scientific concepts of ultimate causes and proximate causes are discussed and several examples of proximate causes or proximate mechanisms are given in the section titled ultimate causes and proximate mechanisms. It suggests that an integrative understanding of behaviour must include both a proximate and ultimate functional analysis of. Major depressive disorder is among the leading causes of disability worldwide vos et al.
I read this book about 20 years ago and it still resonates. Within evolutionary biology a distinction is frequently made between proximate and ultimate causes. The ultimate level is the selective advantage behind these actions, ie babies, more robust environment to raise children. Behavioral biology proximate and ultimate causes of behavior. Wikipedia notes that in biology, ultimate causation deals with evolutionary forces that. This lecture introduces students to the study of psychology from an evolutionary perspective, the idea that like the body, natural selection has shaped the development of the human mind. Proximate explanations are closest to the event that is to be explained, while higher, ultimate explanations instead focus on the deeper reasons for why something happened. This has occurred in the literature on the evolution of cooperation, in the cultural evolutionary literature, and in discussions of epigenetics. Behavior is the change in activity of an organism in response to a stimulus. This exists in contrast to a higherlevel ultimate cause or distal cause which is usually thought of as the real reason something occurred.
1635 490 1372 1030 964 893 583 850 1597 897 811 1136 840 727 120 1606 820 492 472 1179 634 456 443 939 1119 952 613 676 698 1363 910 1598 1337 1383 1476 1377 563 302 1330 1074 1033 331 1086 1058 1412 676 1160 417